PINNACLE REAL ESTATE ADVISORS / FAITH BASED CLIENT SERVICES

Colorado Church Real Estate Brokers & Advisors

Church real estate is different. We understand why.

A church building is more than commercial property. We bring church leadership experience and real estate expertise to decisions about selling, purchasing, leasing and repositioning church property across Colorado.

Thomas J. Mathews, Vice President   |   Katheryn Pranno, Associate Advisor
Together at Pinnacle Real Estate Advisors

Discuss Your Property Goals
Why we do this work

We've sat on your side of the table.

Church property decisions are rarely just about real estate. They involve people, history, finances and the future of a congregation.

Our experience in church leadership gives us an understanding of those conversations. We combine that perspective with commercial real estate expertise to help churches make informed decisions about their property.

We know the building matters. We know ministry matters more.

Traditional church sanctuary with wooden pews and pendant lighting
30+Years of Tom's commercial real estate experience
20+Years of Katheryn's ministry leadership experience
How we can help

How can we help your church?

Whether you're selling, relocating, leasing or planning for the future, we'll help you understand the options.

Selling a church

Is it time to sell our church property?

We help congregations understand their property's value, explore their options and navigate a sale with care.

Learn about selling a church
Acquisition & relocation

Where could our church go next?

From existing church buildings to schools and alternative facilities, we help ministries find space for their next chapter.

Valuation & strategy

What is our property really worth?

We evaluate market value, property potential and the options available before a board makes a major decision.

Explore church property valuations
Land & redevelopment

Could our land serve another purpose?

We explore church land sales, redevelopment and opportunities that may support a congregation's long-term needs.

Leasing solutions

Could leasing be a better option?

We help churches and ministries consider church building leasing, sharing facilities and finding appropriate tenants.

Professional resources

Who can help us work through the details?

We connect churches with experienced professionals in construction, financing, architecture, engineering, valuation and legal services.

What to expect

You don't need to have all the answers before calling us.

Some churches come to us knowing they need to sell. Others are considering a move, evaluating an aging building or wondering whether their property could help fund future ministry.

We begin by listening.

We'll talk through your congregation's needs, your leadership's priorities and the decisions ahead. From there, we'll help you understand the market and determine which options deserve consideration.

There's no expectation that you've already made a decision. Our role is to help you make an informed one.

Start a confidential conversation
Historic Grant Street church in Denver, a property previously sold by Tom Mathews
Common Questions

Answers to common church property questions.

Can we sell our church property confidentially or off market?

Yes, depending on your goals and circumstances. Our team can discuss a discreet strategy, selected buyer introductions and the timing of public announcements. No private process guarantees a sale or absolute confidentiality.

Is now the right time to sell or relocate?

We evaluate attendance trends, financial health, facility condition, deferred maintenance and long-term vision to help determine whether to stay, improve, reposition or transition.

How do we determine the value of a church property in Colorado?

We consider location, zoning, condition, land value and potential future uses to assess realistic market opportunities.

Who buys church buildings in Colorado?

Potential buyers may include other churches, schools, nonprofits or redevelopment groups. The strongest option depends on the property and your goals.

How are your services compensated?

We generally work on a success-based fee model, with no hourly consulting charges. Fees and compensation are established in writing before engagement and typically paid upon successful closing.

How do we sell a church building in Colorado?

Start with a market evaluation that considers zoning, building condition, land value, existing ministry uses and alternative buyers. We help church leaders assess options, prepare a marketing strategy, identify qualified buyers and navigate the sale process.

Can a church sell excess land without selling its main campus?

Potentially. A partial land sale depends on subdivision, access, utilities, zoning, entitlement requirements and the congregation’s long-term plans. We evaluate whether a separate parcel or other structure is feasible.

Do you help churches outside Denver?

Yes. Our team works throughout Metro Denver and Colorado’s Front Range, including communities such as Littleton, Centennial, Lone Tree, Highlands Ranch, Aurora and Thornton.

Private & Off-Market Advisory

Not every church wants a sign in the yard.

A building sale can reach staff, members, neighbors and donors long before decisions are final. Some of the best matches never appear on a public listing site. When discretion serves your organization, our Pinnacle team can explore private sale strategies and introduce qualified parties directly. Some opportunities may be available off market, by direct introduction only.

Confidential first conversations

Discuss your options before any announcement. Property information is not marketed or shared without your authorization. Confidentiality agreements can be considered when appropriate.

Discreet buyer matching

When a private approach makes sense, we contact carefully selected congregations, schools, nonprofits and other qualified buyers rather than launching public marketing.

You decide when to tell your people

Your leadership directs the timing and communication to members, staff, donors and the surrounding community.

Off-market opportunities for buyers

Looking for space for your congregation or mission? Contact our team about potential opportunities, including properties not advertised publicly.

Historic neighborhood church with domed roof and brick detailing in Denver, Colorado
Every congregation has a different story. We help find a path forward that fits.
Creative Solutions

Real properties. Meaningful outcomes.

Examples of how thoughtful real estate strategy creates lasting opportunities for churches and schools.

Redemption Hills Church relocation property
Redemption Hills Church · Littleton

Growth Through Relocation

Coordinated a transition from a longtime Littleton campus to the former Elvis Cinemas property, including change-of-use approval.

$2.8M acquisition
Church property associated with Westend Ridge redevelopment
Columbine Hills · Westend Ridge

Unlocking Land Value

Complex entitlement and redevelopment work helped reposition church-owned property for a 102-lot residential community.

$4.9M sale
Church campus
Cornerstone Church · Ambleside School

Securing Long-Term Campus

Helped secure a 53,170 SF permanent school campus on 7.39 acres in Lone Tree, including rezoning for school use.

$9M acquisition
Track Record

Selected completed transactions.

A selection of successfully completed transactions highlighting our experience in church, school and nonprofit real estate. These properties have sold and are not currently available.

PropertyLocationSizeSale dateSale price
Redemption Hills Church ConversionLittleton34,461 SFMar 2026$2,800,000
Westend Ridge RedevelopmentColumbine Hills10.77 ACJun 2025$4,900,000
Cornerstone Church / Ambleside SchoolLone Tree53,170 SFAug 2024$9,000,000
Coram Deo Reformation ChurchCentennial9,840 SFAug 2023$2,200,000
Church · 2535 & 2575 Vine StreetDenver12,680 SFDec 2022$2,100,000
Universal ChurchDenver16,775 SFAug 2021$1,750,000
LifeGate ChurchDenver42,766 SFNov 2020$4,900,000
The Heights ChurchDenver22,295 SFMay 2019$2,800,000
Experience & Relationships

Organizations we have worked with.

A selection of churches, schools, nonprofits and community organizations our team has served.

  • Ambleside School of Colorado
  • Archdiocese of Denver
  • Church of the Nazarene
  • Columbine Hills Church
  • Coram Deo Church
  • Cornerstone Church
  • Covenant Church
  • Life City Church
  • LifeGate Church
  • Mile High Ministries
  • Red Rocks Church
  • Redemption Hills Church
  • South Metro Fire Rescue
  • The Heights Church
  • The Pearl Church
Client Experiences

Relationships built on trust.

“Thank you for being the instrument that allowed us to close.”

Stu Fuhlendorf
Senior Pastor, Redemption Hills Church

“You made a chaotic process for our ministry quite smooth.”

Roger Jones
Director, Where Grace Abounds

“You have been an incredible help through a long process.”

Dr. Virgil Askren
District Superintendent, Colorado District Church of the Nazarene

“What a blessing it was to work with Pinnacle.”

Dr. Anthony Pranno
Senior Pastor, Cornerstone Church

“Thanks again for your fine work!”

Paul Lessard
Executive Director, Covenant Heights Conference Center
Your Advisory Team

Two advisors. One shared commitment to your mission.

Thomas J. Mathews and Katheryn Pranno are commercial real estate advisors with Pinnacle Real Estate Advisors. Faith Based Client Services is a specialized advisory focus within Pinnacle, not a separate brokerage.

Thomas J. Mathews, Vice President at Pinnacle Real Estate Advisors
Vice President

Thomas J. Mathews

Tom brings more than 30 years of commercial real estate experience throughout Metro Denver and Colorado's Front Range. For the past decade, he has focused on churches, schools and nonprofits, combining market knowledge with creative transaction strategy.

tmathews@pinnaclerea.com
303.246.4705

Katheryn Pranno, Associate Advisor at Pinnacle Real Estate Advisors
Associate Advisor

Katheryn Pranno

Katheryn brings more than 20 years of executive leadership experience in ministry and nonprofit settings. She understands how facilities, finances and mission intersect and helps leaders navigate growth, transitions and complex property decisions with confidence.

kpranno@pinnaclerea.com
720.638.5416

Start a Conversation

Let's talk about your church property.

Whether you're considering a sale, searching for a new location or exploring your options, we'd welcome a conversation. Your message will go directly to our team.

Your message is sent securely through Formspree. We will use your contact information to respond to your inquiry.